A sit-inside kayak has an enclosed cockpit, the opening where you sit inside the boat.1 A sit-on-top kayak has an open deck, the top surface of the boat, with no cockpit around you.1 Makers offer both styles for recreation and gear use.1
Key takeaways for choosing a kayak design
- Choose an open deck if easy access and room to move while casting matter to you.1
- Consider an enclosed cockpit if you prefer a more sheltered seating area.1
- Compare the weight and capacity of the particular models you might buy.
- Check how each maker defines capacity before comparing the numbers.
- Look at the specific storage features and try the fit with a dealer when possible.4
How the two designs differ
Old Town describes a sit-inside kayak as placing you inside an enclosed space, with your legs stretched along the boat. It describes a sit-on-top as a kayak built without a cockpit.1
The open design can make entry and exit easier for some people with mobility issues, according to Old Town, but that does not tell you whether a particular seat or boat will fit you.1 The open deck also changes how the boat handles water around the seating area.
Scupper holes and plugs
A scupper is a hole through the deck that lets water drain. Old Town says open kayaks have scupper holes, but also notes that you are more likely to get wet while paddling or pedaling an open boat. Drain holes do not mean the deck stays dry.1
Perception says its scupper plugs keep water from entering through the scupper holes for a drier ride.5 Viking Kayaks says scupper plugs should not be used when going through surf.6 Pelican specifies small scupper plugs for its kayaks except the Catch PWR, Catch 110 HDII and Catch 130 HDII, which need medium plugs.7
For extended storage, Pelican’s thermoformed-kayak manual says to remove the drain plug and stand the kayak on its stern, or rear end, to empty water accumulated from condensation or seepage.8
An enclosed cockpit can feel warmer
An enclosed cockpit can feel warmer, according to Old Town. The maker says attaching a spray skirt—a cover worn around the paddler and cockpit—can help keep you drier. That is a description of the cockpit and optional cover, not a guarantee that the boat stays dry.1 The tradeoff can matter if you end up in the water.
Re-entering a kayak from the water
Old Town says re-entering a sit-inside kayak from the water is harder, while climbing back onto a sit-on-top is easier. Tom Holtey’s TopKayaker guide describes sit-on-top re-entry as righting the kayak, pulling yourself across the seat area until your hips pass the side, turning into the seat sideways, then lifting your feet into the footwells.9
Most recreational kayaks lack the sealed bulkheads and fitted cockpits that make open-water self-rescue reliable; compare those limits in touring versus recreational kayaks. These are general design comparisons, not a promise about how a person or model will perform.
Old Town also says a sit-inside kayak can be harder to exit after a capsize and harder to right if it fills with water.1 Perception says touring kayaks without sealed bulkheads—internal walls that form watertight compartments—need additional flotation, and describes flotation bags shaped for the front and rear of their longer hulls.10
What makers publish for four models
These examples show how much specifications can differ between named boats.
33 of 295 owner reviews of sit-on-top kayaks mention difficulty carrying or lifting the kayak, so plan how you will lift and transport the boat before buying (owner reviews, not a rate for all buyers).11 Based on published customer reviews, which we do not independently verify for authenticity.
They are not category-wide size or capacity ranges. The table compares maker-published kayak types, dimensions, weights and capacities for four models, checked October 2026.2,3,12,13
| Model and maker’s type | Length | Width | Weight as listed | Published capacity |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Wilderness Systems Pungo 120, sit-inside recreational kayak | 12 ft 2 in (146 in; 370.84 cm) | 29 in (73.66 cm) | 49 lb (22.23 kg) | 325 lb maximum capacity; whether it includes paddler or boat weight is unspecified2 |
| Wilderness Systems Tarpon 120, sit-on-top fishing kayak | 12 ft 3 in (147 in; 373.38 cm) | 31 in (78.74 cm) | 64.5 lb (29.26 kg) | 350 lb maximum capacity; whether it includes paddler or boat weight is unspecified3 |
| Old Town Loon 120, sit-inside recreation kayak | 12 ft (maker lists 3.6 m) | 30 in (76.2 cm) | 54 lb (24.5 kg) assembled (including the parts supplied with the boat) | 321 lb usable; 375 lb total12 |
| Old Town Sportsman 106, sit-on-top fishing and hunting paddle kayak | 10 ft 6 in (3.2 m) | 34.5 in (87.6 cm) | 77 lb (34.9 kg) assembled | 363 lb usable; 440 lb total13 |
Capacity labels do not all count the same thing
Capacity labels do not all count the same thing. Old Town defines total capacity as the assembled boat, people, gear, pets and, where applicable, a motor or pedal console. Usable capacity is what remains for people, gear and pets after accounting for the assembled boat. For the Loon 120 and Sportsman 106, those figures are 321 lb and 363 lb, respectively.12,13
Wilderness Systems describes its Pungo and Tarpon maximums as the maximum amount of gear you might expect to carry on a trip while maintaining a maneuverable, seaworthy vessel. The maker says weight distribution, conditions, paddler weight and size, and skill level affect that assessment.4 Since the makers define these figures differently, do not rank these four kayaks by the headline capacity alone.
Cockpit width and fit
Overall width is not cockpit width. Canada’s Abitibi & Co. lists a 17-by-32-inch (43-by-81-centimeter) cockpit for its Assateague, describing it as sized for long legs and larger thighs.14
The Pungo and Loon product pages listed here do not provide cockpit-opening dimensions, so use a fit check or dealer demo if the opening matters to you. Wilderness Systems calls a dealer demo the best way to ensure the right fit.4 For more on cockpit measurements and fit, see Kayak Cockpit Sizes and How to Judge the Fit.
Storage and fishing features
An enclosed seating area does not mean a boat lacks gear storage. Wilderness Systems lists a dual-lock Orbix hatch, a dashboard with a removable drybox and deck bungee rigging on the Pungo 120. Old Town lists a stern hatch with a bulkhead on the Loon 120. A bulkhead is an internal partition; a hatch is an opening and cover for storage.
Old Town describes the Loon’s hatch cover as water-resistant, not waterproof. It also lists a removable platform that provides space for gear and a camera.2,12 Open-deck kayaks can have storage too, in both open and enclosed areas.
Open-deck storage and fishing
Wilderness Systems describes the Tarpon 120’s large rear storage well for items such as crates, coolers and fishing equipment, plus rails for clipping on fishing, filming or other accessories. A tankwell is an open gear well.
Old Town lists a large open tankwell and a front hatch on the Sportsman 106, along with one forward-facing and two rear-facing rod holders.3,13
Old Town says that being free of a cockpit offers more range of motion for casting. That can make an open deck worth considering if fishing access is a priority, while the named models show that fishing gear and storage layouts vary by boat.1,3,13
The Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission describes a recreational sit-inside kayak fitted with rod holders and gear tracks as a basic fishing option. It cautions that these kayaks are not very stable or comfortable for fishing.15
Choose by the boat, not just the label
Wilderness Systems describes recreational kayaks as designed to track well, or hold a straight course, and turn fairly easily on calm lakes, bays and gentle rivers. That description is for the maker’s recreational category; check the intended use of the model you are considering.4
The Florida Paddling Trails Association says a rudder or skeg can be a big help when you tour in windy areas.16 Academy Sports + Outdoors describes short kayaks as offering maneuverability and a more beginner-friendly experience, though they are not best for top speed.17
Outside reported that the Eddyline Falcon’s sharp bow and finlike stern extension helped it hold a straight course but also made it difficult to turn.18
Fit, carrying weight, storage and stability
A sit-inside or sit-on-top label does not tell you the full story about fit, carrying weight, storage or stability. Old Town says the width that adds stability to sit-on-top kayaks can also make them slower.1 Old Town cautions that kayak dimensions differ, so broad comparisons between the two designs may not apply to every pair of boats.1 Compare the actual dimensions and features, and use Kayak Stability Explained for a closer look at stability.
63 of 156 owner reviews of sit-on-top kayaks from owners who describe paddling one mention the kayak feeling steady while seated.19 Reviews rarely state the paddler’s size, skill, load or water, so they describe impressions, not how the kayak will feel for you. Use a dealer demo to check how steady the boat feels to you.
Inspect the kayak on delivery
59 of 317 customer reviews of sit-in kayaks mention the product arriving damaged; adjusted for the extra one- and two-star reviews in our collection, about 12 in 100 (an estimate, not a count),20 so check the return terms before ordering and inspect the kayak on delivery (customer reviews, not a damage rate).21
Boat styles, body size and seat adjustment
- For a wider overview of boat styles, see The Main Kayak Types and What Each One Is Built For.
- If body size or carrying capacity is central to your choice, read Kayaks for Bigger and Taller Paddlers.
- For help comparing the other parts of a purchase, start with How to Choose a Kayak: Type, Fit and Weight Capacity.
- For seat adjustment and outfitting, see Kayak Seats and Foot Braces: Adjustment and Outfitting.
Footnotes
-
https://oldtownwatercraft.johnsonoutdoors.com/us/blog/sit-in-vs-sit-on-kayaks ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5 ↩6 ↩7 ↩8 ↩9 ↩10 ↩11 ↩12 ↩13 ↩14 ↩15
-
https://www.confluenceoutdoor.com/products/wilderness-systems-pungo-120-recreational-kayak-9730509200 ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4
-
https://www.confluenceoutdoor.com/products/wilderness-systems-tarpon-120-fishing-kayak-9750210201 ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5
-
https://www.confluenceoutdoor.com/pages/wilderness-systems-faq ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4
-
https://www.confluenceoutdoor.com/products/perception-scupper-hole-plugs-4-pack-8080013 ↩
-
Wayback Machine copy captured August 10, 2026 of https://www.confluenceoutdoor.com/pages/frequently-asked-questions ↩
-
https://d1u91ao8a9kulv.cloudfront.net/asset/512740827093/document_l4ia5krspp1k7aontrmhcau637 ↩
-
Well Paddled owner-review count, figure 7142 (October 2026 count). Method: https://wellpaddled.com/about/owner-review-counts/ ↩
-
https://oldtownwatercraft.johnsonoutdoors.com/us/shop/kayaks/recreation/loon-120/0155260704 ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4
-
https://oldtownwatercraft.johnsonoutdoors.com/us/shop/kayaks/fishing/sportsman-106 ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5
-
https://abitibico.ca/en/products/serie-performance-assateague ↩
-
https://www.pa.gov/content/dam/copapwp-pagov/en/fishandboat/documents/education/activitiesandeducationportal/introtokayakfishing_referenceguide.pdf ↩
-
Wayback Machine copy captured January 22, 2026 of https://www.academy.com/expert-advice/how-to-choose-a-kayak ↩
-
https://www.outsideonline.com/outdoor-gear/water-sports-gear/eat-your-heart-out-ahab/?scope=anon ↩
-
Well Paddled owner-review count, figure 7317 (November 2026 recount). Method: https://wellpaddled.com/about/owner-review-counts/ ↩
-
Well Paddled adjusted share (an estimate), figure 934 (October 2026 count, weighted to each listing’s published star-rating mix). Method: https://wellpaddled.com/about/owner-review-counts/ ↩
-
Well Paddled owner-review count, figure 934 (October 2026 count). Method: https://wellpaddled.com/about/owner-review-counts/ ↩